View Single Post
Old Dec 2, 2009, 12:45 am   #14 (permalink)
WindWip
Rationalist
 
WindWip's Avatar
 
Location: Berkeley
Posts: 586
Send a message via AIM to WindWip
Quote:
Quote by: Ender View Post
Eugenics isn't just morally dubious. It is revolting and goes against everything a free society should stand for.
Why does eugenics oppose what a free society should stand for?

Quote:
As hard as it is, if I were to put aside for a moment the gross implications of eugenics, there are non-ethical arguments against it. Eugenics implies we can design life better than God (or evolution if you prefer).
First, I'm an atheist so the God argument doesn't work for me. In any case, evolution in itself shows that improvements can be made to the lifeforms that you believe God created, so I don't quite agree with that argument regardless.

Second, eugenics is practically the process of speeding up evolution, so we most definitely can design life that is superior to what exists today.

Quote:
There are biological reasons for imperfection.
Did you have one in mind?
WindWip is offline   Reply With Quote