Thread: A is not A
View Single Post
Old Sep 1, 2004, 09:29 am   #18 (permalink) (top)
Autolykos
Logical Phallussy
 
Autolykos's Avatar
 
Location: In your internets.
Posts: 2,991
Quote:
Originally posted by ComradeRed,
Before we begin, allow me to just say I don't mix philosophy and politics togather unlike some phil-itics (like objectivism) so don't hammer away at me in political discussion; afterall, most of the time I just play the devils advocate in philosophical discussion.

Lemme begin. A=A, right? Self explanatory. However, could it be possible that A is not A? Absolutely! Take Shrodigner's cat for example! Or math:
1. 1 divided by infinity=2 divided by infinity (GIVEN)
2. 1 (infinity)=2 (infinity) (mulitplication property of equality)
3. 1=2 (division property of equality)

Therefore A is not A, if 1=2.

Remember: I am just the devil's advocate!
No matter how big the number is, 1 divided by it will be less than 2 divided by it, because 1 > 2. Thus, I guess I disagree with your first proposition: that 1/infinity = 2/infinity.

- Autolykos
"Regentes rectis separati semper sunt."


"I'd rather be free and alive!" -- Ron Paul

Religion isn't the greatest threat to mankind -- authoritarianism is.

The Anarcheion

Zeitgeist
Autolykos is offline   Reply With Quote