View Single Post
Old Jul 22, 2008, 07:18 pm   #6 (permalink) (top)
Rogue Cardinal
100% Agnostic
 
Rogue Cardinal's Avatar
 
Location: Stratotopia
Posts: 407
Quote:
Quote by: thrashee View Post
I'd have to disagree. You're supposing that if God actually answers a prayer, that is stating that proof has been given, and according to you, Christians are claiming that they don't need proof.

No intelligent theist is going to cite an answered prayer as objective proof of God's existence. Prayer is inherently subjective.
If God answered your prayer then would it not be proof of his existence?

I am aware of the myriad of ways a person could disprove a prayer. But that's not what I am really driving at.

the point is that if God doesn't need to GIVE any of us proof. In "idea" is argued by Christians that he WON'T. Then wouldn't it be fair to say that you shouldn't pray simply because God wouldn't answer your prayer as it would be proof to at least YOU that he existed?

Thish isn't about objective or subjective proof. It's simply about prayer. Nothing more.


Christians don't know God anymore than you or I do.
Rogue Cardinal is offline   Reply With Quote