View Single Post
Old May 8, 2008, 05:28 am   #53 (permalink) (top)
shrike
Volcanic Erupter
 
Location: Israel
Posts: 2,672
Quote:
Quote by: grandpa View Post
Where did I say that? Let's get something straight: I've also said harsh things about Islam. I've conceded, for example, that the term "Islamo-fascist" isn't much of an exaggeration. Does that mean I'm "bigoted" against Muslims and support wiping them off the face of the earth? By your standards, yes. And who knows, maybe in a few decades I actually would want to wipe all Abrahamic religious groups off the map. After all, religious feuds may pose a threat to my very survival.

My main point, though: I base my view on what happened and why, not on who.
You said you agree with the quote you brought and now you backpedaling. And why you brought Islam to here is like to compare French and Buddhist .You can't stop being a Jew but you can be stop being a Muslim. That why when I criticize Islam is attack on ideology is like when i criticize communism but when someone attack Jewish people it's a racism because Jews is a nation and that's exactly what this bigot did in the first quote and you happily agreed with him.



Quote:
No, it's not the same thing. Hitler said Jews are too prominent in politics AND that Germans need to take over the world. I never said that and, at least in what I quoted, neither did McDonald. Again, we're talking about American Jews, not German politics, and not even about McDonald's personal history. But it bears repeating: I've quoted all kinds of sources in my life, and I'm not going to apologize for the ideology of each author. The fact is, Zionism does influence politics in Washington DC.
Yes many Americans see Israel as main ally in the ME, but not only Jews see this way. There is also Jews that oppose this politic. Mac-Donald generalized about the Jews and that why his arguement is wrong.
shrike is offline   Reply With Quote