View Single Post
Old Jan 2, 2008, 05:03 pm   #41 (permalink) (top)
Chris the Chees
Moderator
 
Chris the Chees's Avatar
 
Location: Wales
Posts: 2,308
Quote:
Quote by: Porfyra View Post
yes but washing with soap is a natural thing that is necessary to keep people clean. tatoos are dumb but that's not murdering a cell because these cells don't have brains like babies. suntan? same thing.

going by your logic, is it wrong to loose skin cells? we loose thousands of skin cells a day just by normal activity. would that be considered immoral?

there's a difference between skin cells and babies.
Quote:
but that's not murdering a cell because these cells don't have brains like babies.
So you attribute human life to 'having a brain', does that mean you base life of the development of brain function; that being the case do you support abortion prior to the development of brain function? Additionaly, is there some point at which brain function reaches a stage which defines humanity, i.e. independent sentient thought?

Quote:
it's the fact that the baby would have been a baby had it not been murdered.
An egg cell could become a baby, does this make it morally incumbent for women and girls to attempt to get them selves pregant or go on the pill in order to avoid having periods? Secondly murder implies that a life has been taken and secondly that life has been taken illegally. To call an abortion 'murder' ignores the latter (because it is not illegal) and shows a misunderstanding of what 'life' actually is.


Society may be formed so as to exist without crime, without poverty, […] no obstacle whatsoever intervenes at this moment except ignorance to prevent such a state of society.

Robert Owen
Chris the Chees is online now   Reply With Quote