Quote:
Quote by: Winter wind  I'm not sure whether you're arguing for me or against me. But if you're arguing against me right now...
If your arguing for me, sorry for arguing your point again and being and ass... |
Yes, I definitely argue for you. I pointed out human mind is a special one as we see from modern development man has made due to that only. But, initial basic data feeding is essential, which in most of the cases birth giving mother, father, relatives or anybody who looks after the infant give for first 10-15 years of age!!!
Quote:
Girl's living with wolves = wolf like intellect
Dog living with humans = Dog like intellect
|
You did agree the first case is correct since, girls did not get that basic human societal data so turned wolf like.
Coming to second case of Dog living with humans = Dog like intellect, I would say:
i) Intellect difference, could be a factor because of which it remained Dog like inspite of living with humans.
ii)
But then, there is also difference in training being given to dog as compared to the human infant. I can not imagine any woman being so affectionate to puppy as she would be to her own new born child. I am also not aware whether anybody has taken that much trouble for bringing up a puppy as is taken to bring up his or her own infant.
However, I have an Octagerian aunt who is issuless and brought up few puppies. Of course not from infancy, but I have seen her caring them as her own children. I have seen them understanding everything what she talks to them. Their gestures and sounds are very much different than a stray dogs. But still, I won't call this training same as we do it for human infant to make her walk and talk as it does develop.
Again, I have seen few pet Parrots talking few sentences like humans due to their master's training.