View Single Post
Old Nov 4, 2007, 09:10 pm   #73 (permalink) (top)
tivodan1116
Juris Doctor
 
tivodan1116's Avatar
 
Location: NY
Posts: 2,433
Quote:
Quote by: rmnunez View Post
Seasonal farm workers move from field to field across the US at harvest time, they don't come from where the harvest is. There are hundreds of miles between jobs, farmworkers can't commute from home to the worksite.
Maybe that's true in the west, but in the east where there are more native unemployed, workers stay in one area for an entire season.

Either way, moving from place to place is just another reason why Americans aren't doing the job. It's difficult work, and again, suggestions by others that immigrants are "taking" these jobs from Americans are just silly.

Quote:
Suggestions welfare recipients could do the job if denied benefits are senseless, the costs would be outrageous, most welfare recipients are female and have minor dependants, you'd need to provide housing, daycare, schooling and medical services, and plenty of welfare recipients would still be unemployable due to other handicaps. If you set off from the proposition to revoke any of their rights to public assistance there'd be savings since no housing, daycare, school or medical service would be required, but I suspect you'd have a revolution before they gave up these benefits.
Very true. You're not arguing me here. I'm merely showing why a steady flow of hard working immigrants is necessary to the economy.


"But it wasn't until he met his beautiful wife that he learned using logic and reason isn't enough. You have to be a dick to everyone who doesn't think like you." - South Park on Richard Dawkins
tivodan1116 is offline   Reply With Quote