View Single Post
Old Nov 2, 2007, 12:16 pm   #3 (permalink) (top)
grandpa
blasphemer
 
grandpa's Avatar
 
Location: Michigan
Posts: 8,466
Quote:
Quote by: Scribbler1 View Post
To answer the question posed in the thread title, he
was a soldier doing his duty.
Nothing more than that.
So because one puts on soem uniform he/she is beyond standard moral consideration? That's one aspect (among many) of statecraft I've never been able to get behind. We should eventually come to realize that soldiers actually do commit acts, that a great deal of tyranny happens because of their enacting policies. I think that's an elementary truth, honestly. But states thrive by defeating the introspective critical thinker, so they can divorce man from his own actions.

We should be concerned about those who say "we are nothing more than employees," soldiers or what have you. Such proclamations are a formula for disaster.

Grandpa h.


True morality consists not in following the beaten
track, but in finding out the true path for ourselves
and fearlessly following it. -- Mohandas Gandhi
grandpa is offline   Reply With Quote