View Single Post
Old Oct 17, 2007, 05:13 pm   #17 (permalink) (top)
grandpa
blasphemer
 
grandpa's Avatar
 
Location: Michigan
Posts: 8,720
Quote:
Quote by: GHook93 View Post
I know I know you are an anarchist!
But you usually argue for the creation of a Palestinian
State (which is a just cause), so you I'm against
all states stance is hyprocritical.
You haven't illustrated any hypocrisy. I never advocated a Palestinian state, at least not that I recall.
In fact, I've responded directly to you on this issue before.
I once typed, "...I think we need to consider a 'no-state' solution."
I then provided the following link, which is very well argued and written:
The Gulf war- No state solution is a good solution

Anyway, my posts here contradict your premise that opposing Israel is instantly "anti-Semitic."
Just as bad is how harsh criticism of Israel supposedly instantly equals lying.

You may be right about one thing, though. If one is opposed to a Palestinian or Muslim state, they should oppose a Jewish or Christian one as well.

Grandpa h.


"Check yourself before you wreck yourself."
- Ghandi.
grandpa is offline   Reply With Quote