| The phrase "voluntary tax" only makes sense if one defines "tax" simply as "a contribution to the government for its services". This definition does not take into account the means by which the contribution is made, leaving both voluntary and involuntary contributions as possibilities.
However, even if the government were to (try to) fund its services entirely from voluntary contributions, it would still (attempt to) reserve for itself an exclusive right to provide those services. In other words, the government would not allow (all other things being equal) separate, private agencies to provide the services in question.
If the government suddenly decided to rely only on private contributions, I would give it nothing. On the other hand, I would use my tax savings to contribute more generously to private welfare organizations (i.e., charities) and the like. Also, when private companies take over the building and maintaining of infrastructure, due to the government itself going bankrupt, I will gladly pay those companies for their services -- when I use them.
- Rob |