View Single Post
Old Jul 17, 2007, 09:35 pm   #3085 (permalink) (top)
O-dehlay
Molten Ash
 
Posts: 59
Quote:
Quote by: CoffeeSaint View Post
No, you are correct; any baby of any development can be killed all the way up until the birth. However, logic does not always equate to reason, as I don't believe that any reasonable person would support the abortion of a fetus two minutes before birth, even though the logic of the argument allows this. If forced into a black and white decision, yay or nay, then the logical answer must prevail; but perhaps we can find an accommodation that allows for reason, as well as logic -- humanity as well as legality.
Quote:
Quote by: O-dehlay View Post
Well in the window of time we are talking about I think both logic and reason would dictate a decision in favor of the fetus. How do you feel it is still logical to abort the fetus at this point? 2 mins before birth for clarification
Quote:
Quote by: Osborn F Enready View Post
Have you not read my previous answers?

You can't abridge a LEGAL, INDIVIDUALs rights in favor of a "potential" persons rights, since they have no rights.

The problem is more of a "im reading answers that someone else has posted and you are not reading those answers".

View the bolded. I wish to know in what way a baby who is capable of living on its own being removed from the mother (this is two mins before birth) can be killed logically under the same prinicples of the early fetus. We have already established that "no reasonable person would do such a thing" but I wish to know the logic behind the decision he is speaking about.
O-dehlay is offline   Reply With Quote