Quote:
Quote by: grandpa  Well, it's hard to discuss an issue when you assume all human motivations and knowledge would be on the brink of extinction in a less hierarchical, more egalitarian society.
That's an irrational assumption, and I know as much by logical deduction.
This is nonsense. The Spanish anarchists would have thrived much better if they weren't being attacked. It wan't a necesssary condition.
In addition to this bizarre assumption, you
1. fail to research into the Spanish Revolution
2. assume they had no clue what they were doing
Those two things reveal your ideological bias.
Please read this and get back to me: Infoshop.org - An Anarchist FAQ - I.8 Does revolutionary Spain show that libertarian socialism can work in practice?
It wasn't only rural:
These accomplishments should impressive anyone in light of other things going on, and it simply makes sense innovation would have occured.
Grandpa h. |
I am basing my comments upon yours- that people will figure these things out as they go along, that they will "organise" their society as they best see fit. The problems that such a community, any community, will have to deal with will not magically vanish, as you seem to insist it will. It still has to be solved. Saying people will figure it out does not inspire confidence.