View Single Post
Old Mar 28, 2007, 01:02 pm   #25 (permalink) (top)
Captain Chaos
Shifting Paradigms
 
Captain Chaos's Avatar
 
Location: Flowery Branch, GA
Posts: 3,102
My mother in law possesses very liberal religious beliefs. Nothing at all offensive about her brand of Christianity.

However, she has this one particularly irrational belief that just drives me nuts.

A typical conversation between us goes like this:

Her: I will pray for him to get better
Me: Do you believe that praying will increase the odds that God will intervene oh his behalf?
Her: Yes
Me: So, then, God is less likely to intervene if you don't pray for him?
Her: Well, now, I didn't say that.
Me: Look, if God is more like to intervene after prayer, then he is less likely to intervene before prayer. This is simple. If A is greater than B, then B is less than A.
Her: You really can't apply math to things like prayer and God.


I cannot tell you how much such vacuous reasoning bugs the unholy crap out of me.

I love her, I like her, and I appreciate the help she gives us in getting my daughter to and from school.

But I despise insane reasoning.


Do all things with love.
Captain Chaos is offline   Reply With Quote