View Single Post
Old Feb 19, 2007, 06:24 pm   #18 (permalink) (top)
Kamehameha34
The dingos!
 
Kamehameha34's Avatar
 
Posts: 4,457
Quote:
firstly. the analogy doesn't suggest ANYTHING to be TRUE, or UNTRUE.
So it's ultimately meaningless.


Quote:
he makes a suggestion that seems quite outlandish, that is, a being a teapot in space, in orbit around the sun. that is a claim he made up. nothing was said to be true or untrue, but seeing he made up the claim,
Outlandish meaning ridiculous. That's the whole point of the comparison. To make the god claim look "ridiculous."

Quote:
it is only rational to assume that it is untrue, not due to it being ridiculous, but due to there being no proof for it.
Ad ignoratium.

No proof for the positive =/= proof for the negative.
Kamehameha34 is online now   Reply With Quote