[Praxius]

Quote by: KillerArgument Please spare me your emotional reaction and respond with reason. No, it didn't mess up my logical defense--you didn't address the moral issue. Once again: In beheading your infant son, who by your definition is not alive, was there any crime done?

I did answer your question and if you missed it:

If they were caught, they would have plenty of charges coming their way as it is, besides your baby murder idea, to keep them in jail for a long time.

Your logic is flawed in my reasoning because if we decided to have an abortion that's one thing..... that's our decision alone weither or not we want to bring a life into this world or not. It's another thing if you came along and made the decision for us, much like how you are telling me that I shouldn't... much like if you came along and attempted your hypothetical situation.

Hence why I don't think your situation is a valid defense for your opinion. As I said, I have more vale over my wife's life then that of the unborn fetus.

I can't elaborate anymore then that... because that's the only answer I have for your question.

Would a crime be committed? Yes. Would it be the crime you are seeking? No.

I doubt that positing a gruesome hypothetical scenario qualifies me for more moral guilt than for those who commit the monstrous evil of murdering their own unborn sons and daughters.

Hence why I think your reasoning for the value of human life is flawed. You brought in a hypothetical situation where you would have caused harm to both my wife/girlfriend and the unborn fetus..... you selected me to decide my opinions on what was done to the fetus, without regard to the wife/girlfriend, where in my opinion, is far more important.

I have a greater chance of having another child, then I would finding a replacement for my wife/girlfriend.