View Single Post
Old Nov 29, 2006, 09:05 pm   #6 (permalink) (top)
Castle
Igneous Magma
 
Castle's Avatar
 
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 265
Quote:
Quote by: CoffeeSaint
Before birth it relies on the mother for its continued existence. After birth it does not.
This is inaccurate. It is possible to for a fetus to survive (not sure exactly when this occurs, but I know its before birth) without the mother (on special machines and things, obviously). Babies are also very dependent on parents for quite a while after birth.

And since when was (lack of) dependency a requirement for personhood?

Quote:
Quote by: pandaz xx
The "fetus" isn't a baby until about 5 months.
Sorry if I didn't verify that.
What precisely is the reasoning behind that distinction (that the fetus is deserving of rights after 5 months)?

Quote:
Quote by: pandaz xx
You shouldn't just not have a baby if you can give it up for adoption.
Why not? What's the problem with it?
Castle is offline