View Single Post
Old Apr 29, 2004, 02:19 am   #4 (permalink) (top)
Jet
Molten Ash
 
Location: NoCal
Posts: 106
The fact that it's old doesn't make it good. And in fact, it doesn't work; the modern list of rights has had to be written by the courts because the bill of rights is so vague; the electoral college stopped being useful around 1820; the list of Congressional powers is very lacking in a modern society; and so on. The reason it's not been rewritten is that Americans have had blind faith in it, not the other way around, and that there's never been broad enough a coalition for a complete rewrite.


Now, GreatWyrm, you've just explained why there should be a constitution, but not why the current one is good.


The world exists. Everything else is just a corollary.

Just an irregular Joe...

Visit Open Source Politics or my site
Jet is offline   Reply With Quote