Dawkins isn't a philosopher -- he's a biologist. I find his models to be far to tied to his pre-conceptions of genes causing everything (his theories generally end up being extremely reductionistic; which is messy). The line of his that probably bugs me the most is (from
The Selfish Gene):
Quote:
| We are survival machines - robot vehicles blindly programmed to preserve the selfish molecules known as genes. |
Your explanation does not get away from determinism. It doesn't matter if I understand how my brain functions (luckily, because I don't). If it functions and its functioning is fully constrained by my biology/environment interaction, then there is no free will -- we are blind robot vehicles.