View Single Post
Old Jul 30, 2005, 03:01 pm   #1208 (permalink) (top)
Isaiah
Strength and Honor
 
Posts: 80
Quote:
Quote by: SoccerfreakAB2
Wrong. I think you are a human and I am pro choice. So you are wrong. Don't be so eager to sum up the pro choice argument in one sentence. I understand full well that you are human.
I think you missed Pale Rider’s point. He was saying that the pro-abortionists must believe that the unborn child is not a person/human being and that after birth they are. If they did not hold this belief then they would all support an action that is a violation of the unborn person’s Constitutionally-guaranteed rights.

The 14th Amendment provides that “nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws” and therefore if the unborn child is a person, then they cannot be deprived of life without the due process of law, including a trial by jury etc. Therefore the pro-abortion movement and every person holding a pro-abortion stance must believe that the unborn child is not a person.

Pale Rider was saying that anyone who is pro-abortion, must believe that, at some point in time, every person must have not been a person. Your statement was that you believed him to be a person NOW but that is not what he was saying. Therefore you did not answer his assertion which still stands, and as I have shown, is a logical and legal necessity of the pro-abortion movement here in the US.


Hopefully more light than heat
Isaiah is offline   Reply With Quote